On difference that makes a difference and how some things come to matter and others don't. Political agency and subjectivity in Karen Barad’s feminist new materialism
Article Sidebar
Google Scholar citations
Main Article Content
The following essay is a critical investigation into the political within feminist new materialisms. Agency, identity and subjectivity are complexified in new materialist theories, although not entirely done away with. They are understood as the complex product of a material-discursive, nature-cultural web of relations from which a feminist political subjectivity might emerge in its always situated and situational instantiations. However, while feminist new materialisms offer complex insights into the transient nature of boundary drawing practices, destabilizing binary conceptualizations of subject and object, matter and discourse and the like, our focus in this article is on how such complexifications can ground a feminist politics proper, in particular concerning the work of feminist quantum physicist and philosopher Karen Barad. Using the conceptual tools developed by Peta Hinton (2014) and Catherine Malabou (2011), our argumentation works through Barad’s notions of objectivity, accountability, agency and subjectivity. At the core of the article lies the question of whether Barad’s realist notion of objectivity and accountability could allow for the recognition of commonalities and common histories in cuts and marks left on bodies in order to bring forth a certain kind of feminist (potentially collective) identity that could think and work towards political change. By working through the complementarity principle developed by Niels Bohr and its further elaboration by Karen Barad, the argument points at the conceptual problems arising from the complementarity of “truth and meaning” for envisaging political subjectivity. Rather than working towards resolving or collapsing the conceptual and material problematic of complementarity, a conclusion is drawn by thinking through Barad’s grounding of agency and processes of materialization, bearing in mind Malabou’s notion of plasticity and her call for a minimal concept of female essence, with the idea being to craft material-discursive apparatuses that could enable the tracing of a politics based on embodied historicities of matter.
Keywords:
Article Details
Copyright
For all articles published in Artnodes that are subject to a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence, copyright is retained by the author(s). The complete text the license can be consulted at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. You may copy, distribute, transmit and adapt the work, provided you attribute it (authorship, journal name, publisher) in the manner specified by the author(s) or licensor(s).
Authors are responsible for obtaining the necessary licences for the images that are subject to copyright.
Assignment of intellectual property rights
The author non exclusively transfers the rights to use (reproduce, distribute, publicly broadcast or transform) and market the work, in full or part, to the journal’s editors in all present and future formats and modalities, in all languages, for the lifetime of the work and worldwide.
I hereby declare that I am the original author of the work. The editors shall thus not be held responsible for any obligation or legal action that may derive from the work submitted in terms of violation of third parties’ rights, whether intellectual property, trade secret or any other right.
Franziska Aigner, Kingston University
Franziska Aigner is an MA student in Philosophy and Contemporary Critical Theory at CRMEP, Kingston University. Apart from her interest and engagement with feminist theory as well as continental philosophy, she is active as an artist working in the fields of choreography and performance.
Katja Čičigoj, Graduate Center for the Study of Culture (GCSC) at the Justus-Leibig University, Giessen
Katja Čičigoj is a PhD candidate at the Graduate Center for the Study of Culture (GCSC) at the Justus-Leibig University, Giessen, Germany. She has graduated from Philosophy and Comparative Literature from the University of Ljubljana. She has been working as a writer, editor, translator, lecturer and sometimes practitioner in the fields of philosophy and the humanities, contemporary art, performing arts and film. She is interested mainly in feminist and political theory and continental (poststructuralist) philosophy.
Similar Articles
- Victoria Messi, Proxemia: a sociotechnical analysis of an electronic artwork , Artnodes: No. 16: (November 2015). NODE 16. Art Matters II (Editor: Ana Rodríguez Granell)
- Aurelio Castro Varela, Cinefòrum Poble Sec as a “school” for the commons: a situated device versus modes of address , Artnodes: No. 17: (June 2016). NODE 17. Art and Education (Editor: Aida Sánchez de Serdio)
- Jaron Rowan, Marta Camps, Design research: suturing bodies, puppies, epistemologies and moons , Artnodes: No. 20: (December 2017). NODE 20. Art and Research (Editors: Pau Alsina, Ana Rodríguez, Irma Vilà Òdena)
- Pau Alsina, Ana Rodríguez, Vanina Yael Hofman, Becoming of Media Archaeology: paths, knowledge and methodologies , Artnodes: No. 21: (June 2018). NODE 21. Media Archaeology (Editors: Pau Alsina, Ana Rodríguez, Vanina Hofman)
- Marina Pastor, Moises Mañas, Media-apocalypse. Dissection, regeneration, and repair: agents for the development of technocratic-ludic zombie systems , Artnodes: No. 21: (June 2018). NODE 21. Media Archaeology (Editors: Pau Alsina, Ana Rodríguez, Vanina Hofman)
- María Remedios Fernández Ruiz, Gloria Corpas Pastor, Miriam Seghiri, The reception in Spain of African literature written in English: statistical data generation using the specialised bibliographic database BDÁFRICA , Artnodes: No. 22: (November 2018). NODE 22. Digital Humanities: societies, policies, knowledge (Editor: Nuria Rodríguez-Ortega)
- Ana Rodriguez Granell, Editorial: The impact of technology on certain historiographic issues , Artnodes: No. 23: (January 2019). NODE 23. Media Archaeology II / Digital Humanities II (Editor: Ana Rodriguez Granell)
- Raúl León-Mendoza, What does an image prove? , Artnodes: No. 24: (July 2019). NODE 24. After post-truth (Editor.: Jorge Luis Marzo)
- Raquel Caerols Mateo, Beatriz Escribano, Medialab Madrid 2002-2006. Participatory culture and social activism in Madrid , Artnodes: No. 24: (July 2019). NODE 24. After post-truth (Editor.: Jorge Luis Marzo)
- Mónica Bello Bugallo, Andy Gracie, Black Holes and Objectivity , Artnodes: No. 25: (January 2020). NODE 25. Dialogs Between Art and Fundamental Science (Guest Editors: M. Bello & A. Gracie)
You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.